UNESCO’s Museum of Stolen Art Hopes to Empty Itself!

Every year, 14 November is observed as the International Day against Illicit Trafficking in Cultural Property, proclaimed by UNESCO in 2019. It reminds us that the theft and illegal trade of art and antiquities is not merely a matter of stolen property. When a temple sculpture disappears, a manuscript is smuggled out of a monastery, or an archaeological artefact is dug out and sold clandestinely, a piece of a community’s history and identity goes with it. The trade is global, lucrative and often connected to organised crime. It also raises uncomfortable questions about the journeys of objects that now grace some of the world’s most prestigious museums and private collections.

Among the initiatives to combat this trade is UNESCO’s Virtual Museum of Stolen Cultural Objects, launched in September 2025. It is a museum with a rather unusual ambition: to see its galleries gradually emptied. For every object returned to its rightful home, there is one less exhibit to display. And that, quite literally, would be a measure of its success.

A museum without walls

First, this is a completely virtual museum. There is no physical building, no collection of original artefacts and no objects displayed in glass cases. It is an immersive digital experience, accessible to visitors around the world through its website. (Though quite frankly, I found the virtual experience quite difficult to navigate!).

Designed by Burkina Faso-born architect Francis Kéré, winner of the prestigious Pritzker Architecture Prize, the museum takes its inspiration from the baobab tree. Developed in collaboration with INTERPOL and supported by Saudi Arabia, the museum was launched at the 2025 MONDIACULT conference in Barcelona.

The museum has three principal spaces: a Gallery of Stolen Cultural Objects, an Auditorium and a Return and Restitution Room. The gallery brings together objects reported stolen from countries across the world, ranging from sculptures and paintings to manuscripts. Photographs, 2D digitisation and 3D digital reconstructions help visitors examine the objects and understand their origins, significance and circumstances of disappearance. Narratives from affected communities explain why these objects matter beyond their artistic or monetary value. The Return and Restitution Room documents successful recoveries.

Countries themselves nominate objects for inclusion. For the initial collection, these must be listed in INTERPOL’s Stolen Works of Art Database. UNESCO invites Member States to select objects whose disappearance represents a significant loss to their cultural heritage. This is not intended to be a comprehensive catalogue of everything stolen around the world.Currently, there are 240 items from 46 countries listed.

Importantly, the appearance of an item in the virtual museum does not mean they have been recovered. Their digital presence makes their loss visible; their physical return remains the ultimate objective.

India’s three missing treasures

India has nominated three objects for the initial collection, all sculptures from temples in Chhattisgarh.

The first is a ninth-century sandstone sculpture of Shiva as Nataraja, from the Mahadev Temple at Pali. Shiva is depicted in his cosmic dance, with four arms and one foot pressing down upon a demon, symbolising the triumph of knowledge over ignorance. Nandi, sits nearby.

The second is a sculpture of Brahma, the creator, also from the Mahadev Temple at Pali. Depicted with three visible faces and four arms, Brahma is accompanied by his vahana.

The third is Bhairava, a fierce manifestation of Shiva, from the Bhairav Baba Temple at Dantewada, depicted with four arms, dancing on a corpse and carrying a drum and dagger.

Why these three? UNESCO asked countries to nominate objects of particular cultural importance whose disappearance had appreciably impoverished their national heritage. India chose these three rather than attempting to list all its missing antiquities. Their inclusion draws attention to the loss experienced by the communities from which they disappeared.

A worldwide business in stolen heritage

The scale of the problem is enormous, although no one can reliably calculate the total number of stolen cultural objects worldwide. The trade spans continents and centuries. Objects have been taken through colonial plunder, wartime looting, clandestine excavations, and thefts from museums and temples. Some are sold through auction houses and private dealers, sometimes accompanied by forged ownership histories; others disappear into private collections.

INTERPOL’s Stolen Works of Art Database contains descriptions and photographs of almost 57,000 objects, based on information supplied by authorised national authorities. This is only a record of identified and reported cases, not a measure of the entire illicit trade.

India has been particularly badly affected. Temple sculptures, bronze icons, archaeological objects and manuscripts have all been targets. Chola bronzes are especially sought after.

There have, however, been encouraging recoveries. Four idols of Rama, Sita, Lakshmana and Hanuman, stolen from the Rajagopal Vishnu Temple in Anandamangalam, Tamil Nadu, in 1978, were traced to the UK and returned in 2020.

In 2026, the Smithsonian’s National Museum of Asian Art agreed to return three Indian bronzes following research establishing that they had been illegally removed from temples in Tamil Nadu. These included a Chola-period Nataraja, a Somaskanda and a sculpture of Saint Sundarar with Paravai. In April 2026, US authorities also announced the return of 657 antiquities to India, recovered through investigations into international trafficking networks.

These successes are encouraging, but they represent only a fraction of what has disappeared.

Bringing the past back into the present

One of the most interesting things about UNESCO’s initiative is that it changes the way we think about stolen art. An ancient sculpture is not just an object with an estimated market value. It belongs to a particular place, a particular history and often a continuing tradition of worship or community life.

A virtual museum cannot bring these objects home. Nor can a digital reconstruction replace the experience of encountering an original work of art in its rightful setting. But it can make the world aware of what has been lost, help establish provenance, encourage vigilance in the art market and create pressure for restitution.

This museum’s ambition is not to become another great repository of the world’s treasures. It hopes to work itself out of existence, one recovered object at a time.

For a museum, that is a rather interesting aspiration.

–Meena

Pic: https://museum.unesco.org/

Sandwiches: A World Between Two Slices of Bread

November 3 is National Sandwich Day, and the story behind the name involves an English aristocrat, a gambling table and a convenient way of eating without putting down one’s cards.

John Montagu, the Fourth Earl of Sandwich, lived in eighteenth-century England. According to the popular story, he was so engrossed in gambling that he asked for meat to be served between two slices of bread. He could eat with one hand and continue playing with the other. His fellow gamblers began asking for what Sandwich was having, and a culinary institution was born.

Or so the story goes. The precise circumstances are uncertain, and people had been eating food wrapped in or placed between bread long before the earl came along. The word sandwich, however, acquired its modern culinary meaning in eighteenth-century England.

The earl could hardly have imagined what his name would come to represent. Today, sandwiches range from the simplest buttered-bread snack to elaborate creations served in fashionable restaurants. And each country seems to have interpreted the idea in its own way.

Of Famous Five picnics and midnight feasts

For many of us, the first sandwiches we encountered in literature were not in a cookbook but in the pages of Enid Blyton. If you remember the Famous Five, you will remember the food almost as vividly as the adventures. Julian, Dick, Anne and George seemed to spend as much time eating as solving mysteries. Their picnics were lavish, their appetites enormous, and their thirst for ginger beer seemingly unquenchable. In Five Go Off to Camp, the children tuck into Spam and lettuce, egg and sardine sandwiches. In Five Go on a Hike Together, there are several varieties, including cheese, pork, ham and cream cheese.

Blyton even wrote A Picnic Party with Enid Blyton, a 1951 book that describes the contents of a picnic basket. Along with egg, sardine, tomato and lettuce, jam, and honey sandwiches, there are fruit cake, Swiss rolls and lemonade. Honey sandwiches, she warns, can be rather sticky and messy!

The sandwiches were wrapped in greaseproof paper, packed with boiled eggs and fruit, and eaten on a hillside, beside a stream or in a caravan. They were not gourmet creations, but food that could be carried along on an adventure. Blyton made an ordinary picnic sound like an essential part of an extraordinary childhood.

A world between two slices of bread

The sandwich has acquired some fascinating national identities.

Consider Denmark’s smørrebrød, an open-faced sandwich made with a slice of dense, dark rye bread called rugbrød. It is topped with ingredients such as pickled herring, smoked salmon, prawns, roast beef or liver pâté, often accompanied by pickles and herbs. Traditional smørrebrød can be assembled with extraordinary attention to colour, texture and flavour. Some are miniature works of art.

The Swedish smörgåsbord, despite its similar-sounding name, is something else altogether. It is a spread of assorted dishes, including herring, salmon, cold meats, cheeses and bread. The word has entered English to describe a buffet offering a wide variety of choices. A feast, rather than a sandwich!

Vietnam’s bánh mì tells another story of culinary adaptation. The French introduced baguette-style bread during the colonial period, but Vietnamese cooks made it their own. A crisp, light loaf might contain pork, pâté, pickled carrot and daikon, cucumber, fresh coriander and chilli.

The French have the croque-monsieur, a hot sandwich of ham and cheese, often enriched with béchamel sauce and browned until bubbling and golden. Add an egg on top and it becomes a croque-madame.

Japan has its katsu sando, a crisp, breaded pork cutlet tucked between slices of soft white bread, and the creamy tamago sando, filled with egg.

In Cuba, the pressed sandwich combines roast pork, ham, Swiss cheese, pickles and mustard. Different ingredients, different techniques, but the same ingenious principle.

What America puts between its slices

America has developed its own sandwich favourites, some of which are almost institutions in their own right.

The grilled cheese is simplicity itself: cheese between buttered slices of bread, toasted until golden outside and wonderfully melted inside. It is often served with tomato soup, making a particularly comforting combination.

Then there is the peanut butter and jelly sandwich, or PB&J. One slice is spread with peanut butter, the other with fruit jelly or jam. The combination of salty, nutty and sweet flavours has become a childhood staple in the United States.

The BLT takes its name from its three principal ingredients: bacon, lettuce and tomato, usually with mayonnaise. The club sandwich is more substantial, often layering chicken or turkey, bacon, lettuce and tomato between three slices of bread.

Philadelphia has its famous cheesesteak, with thinly sliced beef and melted cheese in a long roll, while Louisiana offers the po’boy, traditionally filled with fried seafood such as shrimp or oysters.

In a 2024 survey of 2,000 Americans, grilled cheese emerged as the favourite, chosen by 42 per cent of respondents, closely followed by chicken sandwiches at 40 per cent. Turkey, ham, tuna and peanut butter and jelly also featured prominently. Clearly, the sandwich is serious business in America!

And then there is India

India, of course, has made the sandwich very much its own.

Mumbai’s famous vegetable sandwich layers slices of potato, tomato, onion and sometimes beetroot between buttered bread spread with green chutney. A sprinkling of sandwich masala provides the characteristic kick. It may be served cold or grilled, with extra chutney and tomato ketchup on the side.

The masala toast sandwich takes the idea further, often adding spicy potato filling and other vegetables before the bread is toasted on a hot griddle. The humble chutney sandwich, meanwhile, is a fixture in many Indian homes. Butter, green chutney and perhaps a few slices of cucumber can transform ordinary bread into an afternoon snack.

Egg sandwiches have acquired their own Indian personality, too. An omelette seasoned with onion, green chillies and coriander, tucked between slices of bread, makes a quick breakfast or evening meal.

And what about vada pav and dabeli? Strictly speaking, these are not conventional sandwiches made with two slices of bread. Both, however, belong to the larger family of portable bread-based foods. Mumbai’s vada pav combines a potato bonda with a soft bread roll, chutneys and often a fried green chilli. Gujarat’s dabeli packs a sweet-spicy potato filling into a pav, adding peanuts, chutneys and sometimes pomegranate seeds.

Indeed, the Indian sandwich is less a fixed recipe than an invitation to improvise. Leftover potato sabzi, paneer bhurji or yesterday’s vegetables can all find a second life between two slices of bread. A little chutney, some butter and a turn on the tava can work wonders.

What makes a sandwich?

That brings us to the key question, what makes a sandwich? Is it the bread? Must there be two slices? Does a filling in a roll count? And can a single slice with an elaborate topping qualify?

There are no universally satisfying answers. The open-faced Danish smørrebrød challenges the two-slice rule, while vada pav and dabeli invite us to look beyond the conventional sandwich.

Perhaps the sandwich’s greatest strength is precisely this flexibility. It can be breakfast, a school lunch, an office meal or a midnight indulgence. It can be frugal or extravagant, vegetarian or non-vegetarian, cold or toasted. It requires neither fine crockery nor cutlery, and is equally at home in a five-star hotel, a school lunchbox or a roadside stall.

This November 3, you could celebrate with a Bombay vegetable sandwich, a Japanese katsu sando or a Danish smørrebrød. Or you could make a batch of egg sandwiches, pack some cake and lemonade, and set off on a Famous Five-style picnic. I will be celebrating with my favourites–cucumber and tomata, and grilled cheese.

Happy Sandwich Day!

–Meena

Bougainville: From Flowers to Struggles for Self-determination

Most of us in India knew only the flower–the bougainvillea spilling over compound walls, climbing gates and brightening our roadsides is such a familiar sight that we rarely wonder where its name comes from. But now Bougainville is appearing in our newspapers for an entirely different reason: a people’s struggle for independence.

What connects the two? An explorer. There cannot be many explorers whose names have endured in such different forms: attached to a flowering plant that brightens gardens across the world, and to a Pacific island whose political future remains unresolved. The story takes us from eighteenth-century France to Brazil, across the Pacific, and into a history of colonialism, mineral wealth and a people’s determination to shape their own future.

The explorer and the flower

Louis Antoine de Bougainville was born in Paris in 1729. A mathematician, soldier and French naval officer, he led a French expedition around the world between 1766 and 1769. Among those accompanying him were naturalist Philibert Commerson and Commerson’s assistant, Jeanne Baret.

During a stop in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, Commerson documented a striking climbing plant. It was later named Bougainvillea in honour of the expedition’s commander. Native to South America, the plant eventually travelled across the tropics, becoming a favourite in gardens far from its homeland.

There is a remarkable footnote to this voyage. Baret had disguised herself as a man to join the expedition, since women were not permitted aboard French naval ships. She is now recognised as the first woman known to have circumnavigated the globe (and probably documented our flower as well).

And those brilliant pink, purple, orange and red displays we admire? They are principally papery bracts surrounding tiny, inconspicuous flowers.

The island behind the name

The same commander also gave his name to an island. In 1768, Bougainville sailed through the southwestern Pacific, and the island now known as Bougainville was named in his honour. But the island was not waiting to be discovered. Its Indigenous peoples had lived there for thousands of years, with their own languages, cultures and relationships with their ancestral lands. The European name records an explorer’s passage, not the beginning of the island’s history.

Bougainville lies east of Papua New Guinea, north of Australia, amid volcanic mountains, tropical forests and beautiful coastlines. Its people have a strong cultural identity and a long-standing connection to their land. One culturally significant Indigenous term is Me’ekamui, associated with sacred land in the Nasioi language, though it is not a universally used name for the entire island.

It is currently an autonomous region of Papua New Guinea, although its people voted overwhelmingly for independence in 2019.

The island’s natural wealth, however, has brought its own troubles.

The mine and the conflict

Panguna is a town on the island of Bougainville in Papua New Guinea. It is the location of the famous Panguna copper and gold mine, which played a central role in the conflict that began in 1988. Developed during Australian colonial administration, it became a major mining operation. Yet many local people felt they received too little of the revenue while bearing the environmental and social costs. Grievances over land, compensation and the distribution of wealth deepened.

In 1988, tensions erupted into armed conflict. The conflict was about much more than mining. At its heart lay questions of who controlled the island’s resources, whose interests they served, and whether Bougainvilleans should determine their own political future. Bougainville’s desire for independence stems from a combination of cultural identity, economic grievances and a long history of political frustration. Its people have cultural and historical links with the nearby Solomon Islands, and many have felt distinct from the people of mainland Papua New Guinea. These differences were sharpened by the mine: while the mine generated considerable wealth, many local people felt they received too little of the benefit while bearing the costs of environmental destruction, damage to their land and disruption to their communities.

The mine closed, and fighting between separatists and Papua New Guinea’s security forces devastated communities. The Bougainville Crisis lasted for years, causing thousands of deaths and immense suffering.

A peace agreement in 2001 established a framework for autonomy and a future referendum on independence. Bougainville acquired its own autonomous government in 2005, while remaining part of Papua New Guinea.

An overwhelming vote, and a long wait

In 2019, Bougainvilleans finally voted on their political future. The result was remarkable: 97.7 per cent voted for independence rather than greater autonomy.

Yet the referendum was non-binding, and its result required consideration by Papua New Guinea’s national parliament. A strong popular mandate, in other words, did not automatically create a new country.

The parliamentary process is now central to Bougainville’s future. Its leaders have proposed independence by 2030, but this remains a proposed timeline, not a settled outcome.

Even independence would bring difficult questions. A new country would need functioning institutions, reliable revenues and the capacity to provide healthcare, education and infrastructure. The future of the Panguna mine will be important, but so will environmental repair, land rights and the fair sharing of benefits.

More than a flower

It is remarkable how one name can connect such different worlds. A French explorer lends his name to a South American plant that finds its way into Indian gardens, and to a Pacific island whose people are still negotiating their future.

The next time a bougainvillea spills over a compound wall, perhaps we might look beyond its cheerful colours. Behind its name lies a history of exploration and the movement of plants across continents. Behind the island’s name lies a different, unfinished story of land, identity and self-determination.

We knew only the flower. Now we know the place, its people, and the story that continues to unfold.

–Meena

Multi-faceted Lexicographer: Samuel Johnson

October 16 is celebrated as Dictionary Day in the United States to mark the birth anniversary of Noah Webster who was born on this day in 1758. Noah Webster is known as the Father of the American Dictionary. Until the publication, in 1806, of his A Compendious Dictionary of the American Language, the authoritative English language resource in America was Samuel Johnson’s 1775 Dictionary of the English Language. However, America had declared freedom from British rule in 1776, and a section of the American population wanted that the newly independent nation should have its own national dictionary. While Noah Webster’s long labour eventually produced such a dictionary, the story of the one of the most famous dictionaries in the history of the English language is equally a tale of another labour of love. 

Samuel Johnson

Samuel Johnson’s Dictionary of the English Language, first published in 1755, took over eight years to compile, required six helpers and listed over 40,000 words. It was a more extensive and complex dictionary than any of its predecessors, a huge scholarly achievement. Each word was defined in detail, and the definitions illustrated with quotations covering every branch of learning.

For nearly a century before Johnson embarked upon his Dictionary there had been a growing feeling within the upper echelons of English society that there should be some sort of standardisation within the English language. In the preface to the Dictionary, Johnson wrote how he felt that the English language was in desperate need of some discipline. In his view, he had found the language to be “copious without order, and energetick without rules”. But it took a whole century before he got his chance to bring some order to the language.

Samuel Johnson was born in Lichfield, Staffordshire, on 18 September 1709. His father was a bookseller. He was educated at Lichfield Grammar School and spent a brief period at Oxford University, but was forced to leave due to lack of money. Unable to find teaching work, he drifted into a writing career. In 1735, he married Elizabeth Porter, a monied widow, more than 20 years his senior. He then moved to London to seek fame and fortune, as well as to further his efforts as a poet. However, he spent several years as a hack writer trying his hand at all kinds of writing, just to make ends meet. The turning point in his fortunes came in 1746.

Over his time in London, Samuel had gradually acquired a literary reputation, and a syndicate of printers commissioned him to compile a ‘Dictionary of the English Language’. This was a lengthy and perilous project, funded by a partnership of booksellers. The booksellers invested in the project because they foresaw good sales, as dictionaries and encyclopedias had a good market in the general public. The partnership shared the costs and the risks, while the copyright of such items usually belonged to the publisher. Thus once the compiler had been paid the agreed sum, he was not entitled to any form of royalty on the sales, while the booksellers made a hefty profit.

In 1746, Samuel Johnson entered into the agreement with the booksellers to write an English dictionary. He began work the same year with only six assistants to aid him. Samuel projected that the scheme would take about three years.  A year later, he was only able to publish a plan for the dictionary in which he outlined his reasons for undertaking the project, and explained exactly how he intended to compile his work. However, he seriously underestimated the scale of the work involved, and in the end it took him three times his estimated length of time to complete his magnum opus.

In the process of compiling the dictionary, Samuel Johnson recognised that language is impossible to fix because of its constantly changing nature, and that his role was to record the language of the day, rather than to form it. Thus he used citations for the words listed, using quotations from a number of literary sources including Shakespeare, Milton, and Spenser. For this he scoured ‘great works’ dating back to the sixteenth century. He managed to select 114,000 illustrative quotations from every field of learning and literature. Albeit, Samuel was also not averse to twisting or rewriting some of the original words to fit the meaning he was trying to convey. However, Samuel Johnson was the first English lexicographer to use citations in this way, a method that greatly influenced the style of future dictionaries.

Samuel Johnson’s dictionary was far from comprehensive, even by mid-eighteenth-century standards. It contained 42,773 entries; but even during Johnson’s time, there were at least 250,000 words in the English language. Samuel Johnson was certainly selective in his choice of words to include. The story goes that several cultivated ladies of London society congratulated the great Doctor for having left all indecent words out of his Dictionary, to which Johnson is said to have retorted, ‘Ah, ladies, so you have been looking for them?’

The dictionary was published in two large volumes on 15 April 1755. The full title was was A dictionary of the English Language: in which the words are deduced from their originals, and illustrated in their different significations by examples from the best writers. To which are prefixed, a history of the language, and an English grammar.

It was not the first such dictionary, but was certainly the most important for that time. In Johnson’s lifetime five further editions were published, and a sixth came out when he died.

From then on Samuel Johnson’s fame was assured. He became known as Dictionary Johnson; but he never made a fortune. Even today, Samuel Johnson is the second most-quoted Englishman according to the Oxford Dictionary of Quotations. Among the quotes attributed to him are: “Patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundrel” and “When a man is tired of London, he is tired of life”. He himself never tired of London where he died at the age of 75 in 1784.

Poet, playwright, essayist, satirist, moralist, literary critic, biographer, editor, and lexicographer–This was the multi-facted “Dr Johnson”, as he was often referred to.

Read more about Noah Webster and his Dictionary https://millennialmatriarchs.com/2021/07/22/from-colour-to-color/

–Mamata

A Hundred Years of Friendship: Winnie-the-Pooh & Co.

It is common to mark the milestone centenary of a popular personality or a historical event, but not so common to celebrate a book and its fictional characters for reaching the hundredth birthday. This week, a centenary celebration marks the debut of a timeless favourite character Winnie-the-Pooh, and his motley band of friends, who have been delighting and comforting generations of children, as well as much older ‘children at heart’.

The little bear and his small gang of Hundred Acre Wood have captivated children’s imagination for a hundred years. Pooh, along with Tigger, Eeyore, Piglet, Rabbit, Kanga, Roo, Owl, and the little boy Christopher Robin were the literary creations of English writer AA Milne.

Alexander Alan Milne was born in London on 18 January 1882. He studied at Henley House School, a small independent school run by his father. One of the teachers at the school was HG Wells. After earning a degree in mathematics from Cambridge University, AA Milne moved back to London where we worked as assistant editor of the humour magazine Punch for eight years. Despite being a staunch pacifist he was drafted in World War 1 and served for the British army. He was injured in the Battle of Somme; and returned to England suffering from post-traumatic stress caused by his experience in the war. He could not take the busy life of London and moved his family to the countryside outside of East Sussex. As he slowly recovered, he spent a lot of time in the woods in the area with his only son Christopher Robin, nicknamed Billy Moon. These woods became the setting for the forthcoming adventures of the Hundred Acre Wood gang of friends.

How did the woods become populated with these characters whose charm has remained undiminished for a hundred years? Christopher Robin himself was introduced by his father in a poem titled Vespers which was published in 1923. Another poem mentions a Mr Edward Bear, which was the name of the toy bear that Milne had given his son on his first birthday. But a visit to London Zoo where Christopher saw a black bear rescued from Winnipeg in Canada, led to the renaming of Edward the toy bear as Winnie. The christening was complete when Christopher told his father about a swan that he fed every morning, and how, if the swan did not come, Christopher would say “pooh” implying ‘I don’t care!’ Thus, on Christmas Eve 1925, AA Milne’s short story The Wrong Sort of Bees formally introduced Winnie-the-Pooh, the teddy bear often dragged down the stairs by his owner Christopher Robin. In no time, the big-hearted, but slightly slow-witted bear won the hearts of all children, and the child-at-heart. In the stories that followed, the little boy and his bear were joined in their woodland adventures by their equally quirky, but loving, furry and feathered friends.

The characters were brought to life by pencil illustrations by Ernest H Shepard. Milne and Shepard were old friends; they had also served together in World War I. The writer and illustrator continued their association through all the books.

Shepard based his drawings on some stuffed toys that Christopher played with in his childhood. However, Pooh bear was based on his own son’s teddy bear named Growler. The original stuffed toys that gave form to Tigger, Eeyore, Piglet, and Kanga are still preserved in the New York Public Library, a bit bedraggled over time, but still tugging at heartstrings.

The first collection of stories Winnie the Pooh was published on 14 October 1926. It was a huge success and helped to introduce the characters to audiences beyond England. The stories with their innate innocence, childhood joys, and idyllic countryside provided comfort in times that still echoed with the brutality of World War I. They also touched upon universal sentiments of friendship and bonding.

In the hundred years since, the books have sold millions of copies worldwide; the characters remain evergreen, and their stories embrace us in a warm reassuring hug. Why do they still tug at our hearts?

The characters are relatable. From the innocent simplicity of Pooh, to the melancholic realism of Eeyore; Piglet’s anxious loyalty, to Tigger’s boundless enthusiasm, we find ourselves comparing these with our own self, and our friends. Wouldn’t it be so boring if all our friends were exactly like us?!

Distinct personalities, each with their own quirks that can be so irksome! But wouldn’t it be so boring if all our friends were exactly like us?! That diversity is what makes the pot pourri so charming. Quibbles and squabbles, all part of life and times in the Hundred Acre Wood. And yet, despite the differences, these friends stand by each other through adventures and mishaps. The friend in need, indeed!

There is no one-upmanship, no one tries to be ambitious, or grand or perfect. The friends accept each other as they are. Cantankerous, timid, scared, anxious, pessimistic, scatterbrained…who is judging here? These traits are not highlighted or analysed, just accepted as an integral part of what makes your friend your friend.  

Life in the Hundred Acre Wood may have its little moments of drama and adventure, but the real “high” for its residents comes from everyday joys—an impromptu picnic; sharing a jar of honey; a walk in the woods, or simply sitting in silence with a friend.

But, to get to this point does require effort. As Pooh reminds us, you cannot just wait in your corner of the forest for friends to come to you; you have to reach out.

Simple and timeless truths. These are being celebrated in different ways this week to remind us, and refresh us. The New York Public Library is hosting a special exhibition featuring the original illustrations by Shepard, the first editions of the 1926 book, and the original stuffed animals that inspired the characters in the stories. The Ashdown Forest in England which inspired the Hundred Acre Wood is planning walking trails and a redesigned visitor centre that looks like a life-sized pop-up book. Perhaps for those of us who have fond memories of Pooh and pals, it is a good time to revisit Winnie-the- Pooh, and savour once again the simple innocence of childhood.

The original books, published following the horrors of World War I, provided a much-needed solace in a time of great sadness, a connection to the innate wonder of childhood. Today as we are inundated with images of hundreds of thousands of children in the world’s many war-ravaged zones; children deprived not only of the basic necessities for survival, but the very innocence and joy of childhood, we need reminders of these very gifts that make life and living worthwhile.

–Mamata

Johnny Appleseed of the Himalayas: Samuel Stokes

In the days before cold storage and “imported” made all kinds of fruits and vegetables available in all seasons, there was a strong seasonal association with these. There were distinct summer fruits, reigned over by King Mango, and bitter karela that matched well with the pungent jamuns in the rainy season. There were the winter favourites ushered in by carrots and peas, and fruits like custard apple and guava.

Growing up in Delhi in those days, for us October was always associated with the Apple season. It was around Dussera time that the Golden Delicious variety of apples made their way from Himachal Pradesh to the markets of the plains. The smooth green crunchy apples had a distinct personality from the red apples from Kashmir. Today these are not easily seen, and not many would even bother to know the difference. An apple is an apple, after all.

The history of apples in Himachal Pradesh is linked with a person whose life and work was a curious journey that took many turns. This was a man who was born in the United States as Samuel Evans Stokes, and died as Satyananda, in the service of the poor in India.

Samuel Stokes was the son of a wealthy American businessman. It was expected that he would continue the family business, but even from his early youth, it was not profit but service that motivated him. This quest led him to join the Christian Quakers religious movement which led him to India as missionary at the age of 22 years. His father initially indulged what he believed was his son’s youthful quest, and even financed his trip.

Stokes arrived in India  in 1904. He began work in a leprosy home in Solan district of Himachal Pradesh. His parents were afraid that he would get leprosy and never return home. Samuel survived, but did not return home.

As he started work with leprosy patients, Samuel realised that he would always be seen as a ‘white outsider’. While he could not change his skin colour, began to dress like the local people and learnt the Pahari dialect so that he could directly communicate. Gradually he integrated with the local community and culture.

In 1912, he fell in love with Benjamin Agnes, a daughter of a first-generation Rajput Christian. Together, they bought a large plot of land in the foothills of the Himalayas and settled there. Harmony Hall became the centre of his new passion–horticulture. However, the poverty of the local people and the need to support them was always on his mind. As Samuel decided to turn to farming and embarked on several experiments in cultivating pear, plum and apples, he began to feel that large-scale fruit growing in the area could help to boost the local economy.

In 1914, Samuel went to America carrying soil samples from his land, and returned with saplings of apples of various varieties that he believed would be suited to the climate and terrain of Himachal. After experimenting with these for a year or two, he found that the Red Delicious variety worked best. Then his mother sent him saplings of the Golden Delicious variety which he added to the mix. While apples were not unknown on the Indian subcontinent, they were mainly grown in Kashmir. The few varieties that grew in Himachal were wild, small, and sour. Once Samuel’s apples were doing well, he started distributing saplings to encourage local farmers to start apple cultivation. They were initially reluctant to replace food crops with fruit which took seven years to yield fruit, but Samuel supported them in the sale and export of the produce as they made the transition. Stokes also built a school for children who worked for him in his orchards in lieu of the fee.

By 1928 apples from Harmony Hall had taken over the Himachal valleys. Samuel also set up a training school for future horticulturists on his estate. Himachal Pradesh officially became the Apple State of India.

Stokes had always fought for the rights of the local labourers in Himachal, and fought against injustice. In the meanwhile, Stokes’ close friendship with CF Andrews led him to Gandhi. The Jallianwala Bagh incident which brutally exposed British violence against people led him to join the freedom movement. He attended the Nagpur session of the Indian National Congress in 1920, and was the only non-Indian signatory to the declaration urging Indians to shun government service. He travelled with Gandhi around the United Provinces to spread the message of swadeshi and soon took to wearing khadi kurtas and churidars, topped with a Gandhi cap. His articles in support of non-cooperation and against British rule led to his arrest for sedition in December 1921. In prison, he protested against the preferential treatment accorded him as a European – he considered himself a British Indian and a Congressman.

Stokes officially gave up politics in 1924 but continued to correspond with Gandhiji. He described himself as more of a philosopher than a politician. He devoted himself to working for the land and the people of Himachal. His own life journey then took a spiritual turn. In a simple conversion ceremony, he embraced Hinduism in 1932, and took the name Satyananda Stokes. His desire to serve remained the guiding principle of his work and life till the very end. He died on 14 May 1946 at the age of 64, and is buried in Kotghar, Shimla.

This season, as we savour the Delicious Apples from Himachal Pradesh, it is a good time to remember Samuel Stokes who can be aptly described as the Johnny Appleseed of the Himalayas.   

–Mamata

 

Went for the Botticelli, Stayed for the Harappan Figurine

There are few relationships as universal as that between a mother and her child. Yet the ways in which we imagine, represent and revere motherhood vary enormously across cultures and centuries. This is the idea at the heart of One Mother, Many Mother Tongues, an exhibition at the National Gallery of Modern Art (NGMA), Bengaluru, curated by Naman P. Ahuja and Andrea Anastasio. Bringing together works from India and Italy, the exhibition spans more than two millennia, inviting us to look beyond familiar images of the mother as nurturer and caregiver. Here, motherhood encompasses protection, fertility, sacrifice, regeneration and even ferocious power. The striking juxtaposition of an Italian Renaissance painting with ancient Indian sculptures makes this more than an exhibition about mothers: it is a conversation between civilisations about what the maternal represents.

The star attraction was billed as Botticelli’s Madonna and Child, but honestly, there were so many works more jaw dropping.

The Italian Attraction

Not to diss the Madonna and Child, painted around 1490 by Sandro Botticelli, one of the great masters of the Italian Renaissance. Seeing a work by Botticelli in Bengaluru is an occasion in itself. The painting depicts the Virgin Mary with the infant Jesus, a subject that Botticelli returned to repeatedly during his career. As per historians, this is not simply a tender portrait of a mother and baby. Look closely, and the relationship seems weighed with foreknowledge. Mary’s red robe evokes her earthly presence, while her blue veil suggests the celestial. Her expression is melancholy, and her hands appear to be opening rather than clasping the child to herself. The infant, meanwhile, seems to gaze beyond the immediate moment, towards a future that his mother may already understand.

In Christian tradition, the infant Jesus is destined for sacrifice, and the painting can be read as a meditation on a mother’s love shadowed by the loss she must eventually endure. It is an image of motherhood in which love does not mean possession: the mother must ultimately release the child to a purpose larger than herself.

The Harappan Mother and Child

But the most goose-bumpy moment was a small terracotta Mother and Child figurine from the Indus Valley civilisation, dating back to around 2500 BCE, loaned by the National Museum, New Delhi. It is modest in scale and material. Yet its emotional appeal is immediate. The mother cradles her baby. The simple act of holding a child is enough.

We cannot know precisely what the maker intended, whether the figurine had a domestic, ritual or other purpose, or whether it represented a particular deity. But the image does invite us to reflect on the enduring human experience of motherhood. Across the vast gulf of time, a small piece of baked clay brings us face to face with a familiar gesture: the holding of a baby close.

Baby in a Basket

Perhaps the most charmingly matter-of-fact image of motherhood in the exhibition is the small (less than 6 inches high) ivory/bone figure from the Shunga–Kushan period, around the 1st–2nd century CE. A mother carries a basket on her head, with her baby girl (yes, you can make out the sex of the baby on such a tiny figure!) safely tucked inside it. If the detailing of her clothes and jewels is intricate, what I found more intriguing was, why was she carrying the baby in a basket on her head? Where was she going? Again, we have no clue about the situation or the artist’s intentions.

The Yogini: Motherhood Beyond the Human

The exhibition becomes particularly intriguing when it moves beyond the conventional mother-and-child image to the world of Indian goddess traditions. The Yogini tradition, associated with powerful female divinities and Tantric practices, does not always fit neatly into familiar categories of motherhood. One of the works highlighted in the exhibition is Vrishabhayogini, a reminder that these figures are not merely idealised representations of feminine beauty or domestic care. The Yoginis belong to a complex religious and artistic world in which female power can be mysterious, unsettling and difficult to contain within a single definition. Their forms and attributes invite us to think about the sacred feminine as something more expansive than the familiar image of a mother holding a baby.

Beyond the Familiar Mother

The exhibition’s other highlights include ancient Etruscan representations of Mater Matuta, a goddess associated with the protection of children, fertility, dawn and renewal, offer a compelling parallel with Indian mother-goddess traditions. The Buddhist goddess Hariti has an especially remarkable story: once depicted in Buddhist narratives as a demoness who abducted and ate children, she was transformed into a protector of children after the Buddha confronted her with the loss of one of her own. Also striking are the Indian Matrikas, or mother goddesses, and the fierce Chamunda, whose fearsome appearance stands at the opposite end of the spectrum from Botticelli’s sorrowful Madonna. A sculpture of Skandamata, the mother of Skanda, adds another dimension to the many ways maternal divinity has been imagined.

One Mother, Many Mother Tongues succeeds in showing us that motherhood is not one fixed image. It is a multitude of stories, beliefs and artistic expressions, each shaped by its own culture.

The juxtapositioning of mothers across geographies and time helps us to see how the mother-and-child motif travelled through different societies and acquired different meanings. Civilisations may differ in their beliefs and artistic conventions; the human bond between parent and child is enduring.

All in all, a wonderful experience!

–Meena

Karni Bharni: When a Jain Manuscript Turned Karma into Pictures

What does karma look like?

It is a difficult question. We can explain karma, discuss it, preach about it and philosophise about it. But how do you actually show it?

Some Jain manuscript makers found an ingenious answer. They turned it into a sequence of pictures: this is what someone did and this is what happened as a consequence. The manuscripts came to be known as Karni Bharni, a phrase meaning “as you do, so you receive”. The Gyan Museum describes them as ‘an illustrated Jain didactic tradition in which actions and their consequences are laid out as a sequence of scenes’. The pictures were important precisely because the argument could be followed even by someone who could not read the accompanying text.

I saw a display of such a book when I visited the Museum of Arts and Photography last week. It is a particularly intriguing subject to encounter around Paryushan, when Jains turn their attention towards self-discipline, reflection, religious study, repentance and forgiveness. At the heart of the festival is the uncomfortable but useful exercise of looking at one’s own actions and their consequences.

Karni Bharni does much the same thing—but instead of asking us to imagine the consequences, it paints them.

These are not quite “picture books” in the modern children’s-book sense. They belong to the long and sophisticated manuscript tradition of Jain communities, particularly in western India. Jain bhandars, or manuscript repositories, preserved texts with remarkable continuity. Their importance goes well beyond religion to contributing to understanding the history of Indian painting, as these are some of the earliest surviving Indian paintings on paper.

And there is something wonderfully practical about the way Karni Bharni works. A page can show an action; another scene shows its result. The sequence does the teaching. The figures are deliberately schematic and punishments quite graphic! Their job is to be recognised and understood.

That makes the manuscripts surprisingly contemporary. We live surrounded by infographics, diagrams, animations and explainer videos because we have discovered that complicated ideas can sometimes be grasped more easily when they are visual. The Jain manuscript maker had much the same insight. Instead of writing several pages explaining the workings of karma, why not show the viewer?

Jain cosmology offered an elaborate universe of different realms, including the human world, celestial worlds and hellish realms. Karni Bharni manuscripts could bring this moral universe alive through images of actions, rewards and punishments. A page might therefore be visually dramatic as well as philosophically serious. Heaven and hell were not distant abstractions; they became places that could be imagined through colour, figures and repeated visual motifs.

The striking thing is that these manuscripts were not produced in isolation. Jain merchants and other patrons supported manuscript production, while scribes and artists developed traditions of copying, illustrating and preserving texts. The result was a remarkable interaction between religion, commerce, scholarship and art. The same Jain communities whose members were active in the world of trade were also among the important custodians of India’s manuscript heritage.

It was particularly appropriate that I saw the manuscript during Paryushan. The festival is not simply about fasting. It is a period of pausing long enough to examine how one has lived. Pratikraman involves reflecting upon transgressions and seeking to repair them; Michchhami Dukkadam, traditionally offered at the end of Paryushan, expresses the wish for forgiveness for harm caused knowingly or unknowingly.

The fundamental question these manuscripts answer is universal. Every parent has told a child that actions have consequences. Every schoolteacher has explained cause and effect. Every society has some version of the idea that what we do eventually comes back to us.

But the Jain manuscript tradition did something more ambitious. It made cause and effect visible.

So, during Paryushan, when the emphasis is on reflection, restraint and forgiveness, there is something rather fitting about looking at these old little books.

They remind us that karma was not always something to be explained in a philosophical lecture. Sometimes it was drawn in ink and colour, one scene after another.

If you would like to see some of this remarkable Jain manuscript tradition for yourself, the Gyan Museum in Jaipur offers a wonderful window into India’s rich heritage of art, manuscripts and material culture. Its collection brings together objects that tell stories not just about religion and art, but about the ways in which knowledge, craftsmanship and cultural traditions have been preserved across generations.

And readers, from us to you: Michchhami Dukkadam!

–Meena

Pic taken at MAP of page from late 19th/early 20th century Kharni Bharni book from Gujarat..

Where Rupee Notes are Born: Happy Birthday Security Printing and Minting Corporation of India

I still believe in cash, and a monthly trip to the ATM is an essential part of my routine. When I look at a ₹10  note, it seems to me, it probably has had a far more interesting life than I have. It may have travelled through a vegetable market, an auto-rickshaw, a school canteen and a neighbourhood shop, survived being folded into someone’s pocket, squeezed into a wallet and perhaps even taken through a washing machine.

This is where an organisation most of us have probably never heard of becomes interesting. Security Printing and Minting Corporation of India Limited, or SPMCIL, is the Government of India’s specialist organisation for making many of the physical objects that underpin our monetary and security systems. It took birth as an entity in September 2006, but it inherited production units whose histories go back much further. Today, its responsibilities stretch from banknotes and coins to security paper, security inks, passports, stamps and other highly secure documents. In other words, while most of us think of money as something we earn, spend or save, there is an entire industrial world whose job is to manufacture it safely.

And this is not a small printing operation tucked away somewhere. SPMCIL operates several currency presses–the Currency Note Press at Nashik and the Bank Note Press at Dewas, as well as the India Security Press at Nashik and the Security Printing Press at Hyderabad. It also has four Government Mints, in Mumbai, Kolkata, Hyderabad and Noida, and the Security Paper Mill at Narmadapuram, besides the Security Ink Factory at Dewas. Each has a very specialised role, because when the product is a banknote, “printing” is really only the visible part of the job.

Consider what goes into making a note difficult to counterfeit. The paper itself is specially manufactured, and the inks are not ordinary printing inks. There are watermarks, security threads, fluorescent features, microprinting, intricate designs, numbering and other security elements, some of which are intended for us to recognise, and others for machines and financial institutions to authenticate. SPMCIL’s Security Paper Mill produced 7,661.61 metric tonnes of security paper in 2024–25, while its Dewas unit produced 601.31 metric tonnes of security inks. Its currency presses produced more than 1.2 crore banknotes in the same year. It also makes passports, stamps, certificates and other documents where authenticity matters. In 2024–25, for example, SPMCIL produced over 1.5 crore passport booklets, including more than a million e-passports, alongside its currency, coin and security-printing work.

The numbers become even more impressive when we step back from the factory and look at India as a whole. At the end of March 2025, there were approximately 1,550.7 crore banknotes in circulation, with a total value of about ₹36.87 lakh crore. That is in addition to coins and the rapidly growing digital forms of money. The ₹500 note dominated by value, accounting for about 86 per cent of the value of banknotes in circulation, while lower denominations such as ₹10 and ₹20 remain important in sheer numbers.

India is preparing to try polymer, or “plastic”, banknotes, beginning with ₹10 and ₹20 denominations. The Government has approved field trials of 200 crore notes altogether, worth ₹3000 crore. The intention is not to banish our familiar paper notes; the polymer notes will initially circulate alongside them, allowing the Reserve Bank of India to see how they survive Indian conditions.

Polymer notes are expected to last considerably longer than conventional cotton-based currency, and that matters particularly for low-value notes that are handled constantly and therefore wear out quickly.

The case for polymer currency becomes particularly interesting when we look at the life of a banknote. Low-denomination paper notes have a relatively short life because they are handled so frequently; internationally, polymer notes have been found to last around 2–4 times as long as conventional paper currency, according to RBI Governor Sanjay Malhotra. The actual life of the proposed Indian ₹10 and ₹20 polymer notes, however, will only be established through the planned field trials and their performance under Indian conditions. The scale is substantial: as of November 2024, India had about 2528 crore ₹10 notes and 1370 crore ₹20 notes in circulation — together nearly 3898 crore notes.

At present, when notes return from circulation, the RBI’s Currency Verification and Processing Systems sort them into fit and unfit notes; fit notes are reissued, while soiled or unfit notes are shredded through the Shredding and Briquetting System and compressed into briquettes. The RBI describes this mechanised process as an environmentally preferable alternative to the earlier practice of burning old notes. For the proposed polymer notes, however, there is as yet no publicly declared Indian end-of-life disposal or recycling system. This is an important gap in assessing their environmental credentials: a longer-lasting note could reduce the number of notes that need to be manufactured and destroyed, but the sustainability story would also depend on how the polymer notes are collected and recycled when they finally become unfit for circulation. International experience suggests that polymer notes can be recycled into other plastic products, but India has not yet announced its own specific recycling/disposal arrangements for the proposed notes

Polymer notes may last longer, but they are still made from a synthetic material, so their manufacture and eventual disposal have to be considered carefully. That is one reason a field trial makes sense. A banknote has to survive Indian heat, humidity, dust, monsoon rains, crowded pockets, ATMs, cash-counting machines and the wonderfully creative ways in which Indians manage to fold, crumple, staple and otherwise abuse currency, otherwise, it cannot be justified from a sustainability perspective. The RBI has specifically said that the notes will be tested for their durability and adaptability to Indian conditions before any wider decision is taken.

If polymer notes are introduced, the SPMCIL printing presses will probably remain central, but the Security Paper Mill’s role in those particular denominations would change. The challenge would move partly from making specialised cotton-based banknote paper to acquiring/producing, testing and securely handling a polymer substrate.

So change is in the wind! Hopefully we, including SPMCIL, can all adapt.

–Meena

Finger Wrestling: The Sport Where One Finger Can Make You a Champion

We use our fingers for all sorts of important things these days: typing, texting, scrolling, swiping and, occasionally, pointing out to someone that they have been on their phone too long.

But in Bavaria, one group of people puts a rather different value on their fingers. They wrestle with them.

Welcome to Fingerhakeln, or finger wrestling—a wonderfully peculiar traditional sport in which two people sit across a table, hook their middle fingers into a leather loop and try to pull each other towards themselves.

And before you dismiss this as something that happens after too many beers at a German village festival, consider this: it has rules, clubs, training, weight and age categories, referees and national championships.

The rules are almost comically simple. Two competitors sit opposite each other at a specially designed table. Their middle fingers are hooked into a short leather strap. At the signal, they pull. The objective is to drag the opponent’s finger across a marked line.

Except that pulling another person’s finger with maximum force is apparently considerably harder—and more painful—than it sounds.

A bout may be over in just a few seconds, although the toughest can last nearly a minute. That may not sound like long enough to constitute a sporting ordeal, until you remember that the entire time is spent exerting enormous force through one finger. Competitors train specifically for the sport, strengthening their hands and fingers and learning how to use leverage, body position and technique.

So if you are now looking at your own hands and thinking, Surely I could do that, please resist the temptation to challenge your spouse, colleague or unsuspecting dinner companion. This is not an after-dinner game. There are good reasons not to underestimate the sport. The finger is subjected to considerable force during a contest, and injuries can occur. Competitors warm up, condition their hands and fingers and develop techniques for pulling and bracing.

               PIC: https://www.euronews.com/

From Alpine tradition to national championship

Fingerhakeln is particularly associated with Bavaria and the Alpine regions of Germany and Austria. Its precise origins are difficult to establish, but the tradition goes back generations. Like many folk sports, it appears to have started as a simple test of strength. Who was stronger? There was no need for a boxing ring or wrestling arena. Just sit down, hook fingers and find out.

Over time, the pastime became organised competition. Today, finger wrestlers compete in different age and weight categories, with regional championships and a German national championship. The sport has managed to remain both fiercely competitive and closely connected to local culture.

In an age when sporting events can involve billion-dollar broadcasting deals and athletes who are global celebrities, Fingerhakeln remains resolutely local. It is rooted in the Alpine region, but the annual German championship gives its strongest competitors a national stage.

The seriousness of the sport becomes obvious when you watch the competitors. There is very little movement and certainly none of the dramatic action associated with conventional wrestling. The struggle is concentrated in the hands and arms, while the two competitors sit almost motionless, each waiting for the other to give way. And then, often within seconds, it is over.

That combination of stillness and sudden force is part of what makes Fingerhakeln so fascinating to watch. It looks almost absurdly simple, until you realise just how much strength and pain tolerance are packed into those few moments.

For all its eccentricity, Fingerhakeln has the trappings of any serious competitive sport: champions, categories, training and even sporting families. At the 2025 Bavarian championships, Franz Foos won the heavyweight title, Andreas Sturm took the lightweight category, while Gerhard Sturm won the senior category for competitors over 60. The Sturms are a nice example of how traditional sports can become family traditions, with skills and enthusiasm passing from one generation to the next.

The Bavarian championship is a regional competition, however, and is distinct from the German national championship. That was held on August 23 in Pflugdorf-Stadl, where around 150 competitors took part. Ferdinand Seitz won the senior title, and afterwards described the experience of competing as “excruciating”—which seems a fairly convincing endorsement of the seriousness of the sport.

For the competitors, the few seconds at the table represented months and years of preparation. And that perhaps brings us to the more interesting question raised by this wonderfully odd sport: what exactly makes something a sport?

We tend to associate sport with speed, spectacular physical feats, enormous stadiums and global audiences. But strip it down and the essentials are rather simpler: physical effort, skill, training, rules, competition and the determination to win. Fingerhakeln has all of them.

It may never become an Olympic sport, but it does not need to. Its appeal lies partly in its connection to place and tradition. In a world where the same sports are watched from New York to New Delhi, Fingerhakeln remains distinctly Bavarian—a competitive tradition tied to its community and passed from one generation to the next.

There is something rather appealing about that. We spend so much time trying to make everything bigger, faster and more spectacular. Finger wrestling goes in the opposite direction. It strips competition down to its essentials: two people, a leather loop, considerable strength and a very determined finger.

For most of us, fingers are increasingly instruments of the digital age, busy with keyboards and screens. In Bavaria, some people still use theirs to settle a much older question: Who is stronger?

The answer, as it turns out, can be decided by a leather loop, a wooden table and a very determined middle finger.

Who knew one finger could carry so much sporting ambition?

–Meena